Senate bill provides for damages for bear-related human death, injury

Article thumbnail

Sursă foto: freepik.com

On Monday, the Senate passed two bills that provide for moral damages of at least EUR 50,000 in the event of injury or death of a person following attacks by wild animals, including bears, as well as the fact that injuring or killing an animal in reaction to its attack will not be a crime.

The first legislative proposal amends and supplements Law 407/2006 on hunting and the protection of the game stock. It passed on a vote of 73 to 16, and 18 abstentions.

Its annexes refer to several wild animals, including the muskrat, chamois, roe deer, deer, wild boar, jackal, marten, fox, as well as the beaver, bear, moose, wolf, lynx, bison, and several bird species.

"In the case of attacks by specimens of the species listed in annexes no. 1 and 2 resulting in injury or death of a natural person, damages would be granted to the victim by the central public administration responsible for hunting and by the central public administration responsible for the environment, which will cover hospitalisation expenses, funeral expenses, and net income not realised during the period when the victim is temporarily unable to work, from the moment the incident occurred," reads the bill.

Also, in the case of attacks by these animals resulting in the injury of a natural person, moral damages of at least EUR 50,000 euros would be awarded to the victim. If these attacks result in the death of a person, compensatory amounts would be granted for the surviving spouse and children of the deceased or, in their absence, for other first-degree relatives covering hospitalisation expenses, funeral expenses, unrealised net income, as well as moral damages amounting to at least EUR 50,000.

The bill also stipulates that the compensation amount for illicit acts for species where hunting is prohibited decreases for bears from EUR 40,000 to EUR 500.

At the same time, the bill also provides that the act of injuring or killing an animal in self defence would not be a crime.

The same provision is introduced by the second bill that passed 72 to 15 and 20 abstentions supplementing Emergency Ordinance 57/2007 regarding protected natural areas, conservation of natural habitats, wild flora and fauna.

Thus, the bill introduces a new article, according to which "the injury or killing of an animal by a person, as a reaction to its attack, does not constitute a crime."

National Liberal Party (PNL) senator Cristian-Augustin Niculescu-Tagarlas said that, in fact, the purpose of these initiatives is to decriminalise poaching acts.

"I have thoroughly analysed and studied this initiative, which is an example of both logical and argumentative dysfunction. Although it regulates four extremely interesting elements that should provoke a heated and passionate debate, in fact the purpose of this initiative I believe is decriminalisation, through the application of a more favourable criminal law, for many who have pending criminal cases of poaching in Romania."

He added that the damages of EUR 50,000 are set "without any kind of analysis, neither jurisprudence nor budgetary impact," warning that a budgetary impact without a fiscal record is an act of unconstitutionality.

"If you walk through the forest and someone attacks you, you can defend yourself, but if you walk through the forest with a rifle and hear a bear, you shouldn't shoot it because, supposedly, you feel threatened, you shouldn't shoot a wild boar or a roe deer as it passes. So, it's a rule made for the hunter who walks through the forest with a rifle on his back and hears a grunt and shoots the bear guaranteed to be threatened," said Tagarlas.

Hungarian Democratic Union of Romania (UDMR) senator Lorant Antal said that the bear is a general danger to public safety.

"I don't know, Mr. PNL senator, if you've ever seen a bear in your life besides the zoo, if not, then I invite you to come to our constituency, for example, Harghita County, Covasna County, Mures County, Arges County, and look and understand what it means to have bears in already exaggerated numbers. I would even say that the bear represents a general danger to the safety of citizens. If today you want to walk in certain forests that are already near villages or even inside villages in these counties, there is a danger and it is part of citizens' daily lives that the bear is practically present among people, and you want to say that if you shoot a bear in defence, you are liable to pay and also to pay for a criminal case because you acted in self-defence."

"If you encounter a bear holding children by the hand and the bear attacks you, you must have the right to self-defence," Antal added.

The Senate is the first body notified of these bills, while the Chamber of Deputies is the decisionmaker.

Google News
Explorează subiectul
București
Temperatură12°C
Noros
România
Vânt1km/h
Citește
mai multe
Articole Similare
Parteneri